I've been on a mega peach polish kick lately. I love them all so much! As I type this there's another peach not included in this post that I obtained. They are just fantastic.
To be fair two of these polishes are fairly easy to get ahold of and two of them aren't so easy to get. But if you happen to have them in your collection or were wondering about whether there was something close out there here's a side by side of Julie G 9 to 5, Julep Hayden, China Glaze Peachy Keen, and Essence It's a Peach Not Cherry.
I think the two most true peach toned would be Julie G 9 to 5 and China Glaze Peach Keen. Julep Hayden is more of a neon hued peach and Essence It's a Peach Not Cherry has more of coral pink tone to it.
Formula wise they all build quite nicely as you can see (all are two coats) and all are cremes.
Julie G is probably my summer pick just due to how creamy and bright it is.